STORYSTAR
Logo
  • Home
    • Short Story STARS of the Week
    • Short Story Writer of the Month
    • Read short stories by theme
    • Read short stories by subject
    • Read classic short stories
    • Read Novels
    • Brightest Stars Anthology
    • StoryStar Premium Membership
  • Publish Story
  • Read Stories
    • READ SHORT True Life STORIES
    • READ SHORT Fiction STORIES
    • READ SHORT STORIES FOR Kids
    • READ SHORT STORIES FOR Teens
    • READ SHORT STORIES FOR Adults
    • READ SHORT STORIES FOR All Ages
    • Read short stories by theme
      • Read Short Love stories / Romance Stories
      • Read Short Family & Friends Stories
      • Read Short Survival / Success Stories
      • Read Short Mystery Stories
      • Read Short Inspirational Stories
      • Read Short Drama / Human Interest Stories
      • Read Short Action & Adventure Stories
      • Read Short Science Fiction Stories
      • Read Short Fairy Tales & Fantasy Stories
      • Read Short Story Classics Stories
      • Read Short Horror Stories
      • Read Short Gothic Stories
    • Read short stories by subject
      • Action
      • Adventure
      • Aging / Maturity
      • Art / Music / Theater / Dance
      • Biography / Autobiography
      • Character Based
      • Childhood / Youth
      • Comedy / Humor
      • Coming of Age / Initiation
      • Community / Home
      • Contests
      • Courage / Heroism
      • Creatures & Monsters
      • Crime
      • Culture / Heritage / Lifestyles
      • Current Events
      • Death / Heartbreak / Loss
      • Drama
      • Education / Instruction
      • Ethics / Morality
      • Fairy Tale / Folk Tale
      • Faith / Hope
      • Family
      • Fantasy / Dreams / Wishes
      • Fate / Luck / Serendipity
      • Flash / Mini / Very Short
      • Friends / Friendship
      • General Interest
      • Ghost Stories / Paranormal
      • History / Historical
      • Horror / Scary
      • Ideas / Discovery / Opinions
      • Inspirational / Uplifting
      • Life Changing Decisions/Events
      • Life Experience
      • Loneliness / Solitude
      • Love / Romance / Dating
      • Memorial / Tribute
      • Memory / Reminiscence
      • Miracles / Wonders
      • Mystery
      • Nature & Wildlife
      • Novels
      • Other / Not Listed
      • Pain / Problems / Adversity
      • Personal Growth / Achievement
      • Pets / Animal Friends
      • Philosophy/Religion/Spirituality
      • Poems & Songs
      • Politics / Power / Abuse of Power
      • Prior Contests
      • Recreation / Sports / Travel
      • Relationships
      • Revenge / Poetic Justice / Karma
      • Science / Science Fiction
      • Seasonal / Holidays
      • Serial / Series
      • Service / Giving Back
      • Survival / Healing / Renewal
      • Time: PAST/Present/FUTURE
      • War & Peace
      • Western / Wild West
  • Contests
  • Blog
  • Comments Feed
  • LOGIN / SIGN UP
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
LOGIN / SIGN UP

Congratulations !


You have been awarded points.
Thank you for !

  • Story Listed as: Fiction For Adults
  • Theme: Drama / Human Interest
  • Subject: General Interest
  • Published: 06/21/2023

The Ice Cream That Wasn't

By Marla
Born 1980, F, from Eagan, MN, United States

Read More Stories by This Author
The Ice Cream That Wasn't
Shelly was gathering kids together for yet another head count before they got on the bus. She was working a day camp all summer, and it was time for the kids to go.

“Don’t forget that tomorrow is ice cream day!” David, another counselor called out.

There were cheers and smiles and bobbing heads as the kids jumped up and down in their excitement. Shelly felt a strange flutter of excitement herself. She was seventeen, a bit old to be eager for a treat, but it had been a long, hot day. The promise of ice cream was one that gave her a happy lift.

………..

The next day came. Though it was only 9:00 a.m., the kids were already talking about the ice cream. Finally, after the morning activities and lunch, David said, “Guess what time it is?”

“Ice cream time!” the kids yelled.

Shelly and the others instructed the kids to sit on the grass in groups. David theatrically brought out a large red cooler. He slowly reached inside and brought out…a popsicle. The happy kids, not caring at all that they were receiving a popsicle rather than an ice cream, cheered wildly. Shelly found herself questioning it. Why didn’t David say anything? Perhaps, “Sorry, it’s not quite the same, but it’s still a treat.” Instead, with a stupid grin on his face he gave each child a popsicle.

Shelly, who loved ice cream, but was not much impressed with frozen Kool-Aid, declined the treat.

“And guess what?” David said. “We have another ice cream day next week!”

……………….


The following week, Shelly and the other counselors were again grouping the kids together on the grass. Again, David pulled out the red cooler. “Who wants ice cream?” This was, of course, met with cheers. Shelly watched as he YET AGAIN pulled out a popsicle!

'How is it that nobody else sees this great error?' thought Shelly to herself. 'One time was bad enough, but twice? Good grief, even the kids aren't saying anything! A popsicle is so clearly, so certainly, so ABSOLUTELY not ice cream!' She remained silent, though.

Shelly glared at David as he offered her one. How dare he? How dare he promise ice cream on a hot day with noisy, sticky kids, and then try to give her a popsicle?

He seemed confused by her angry countenance, but he kept doing his job, handing a treat to each child.

Shelly put aside her annoyance and did her job to the best of her ability for the rest of the afternoon. She didn’t let on to the kids that anything was amiss. As they got on the bus a few hours later, she pictured herself on the couch with a dish of ice cream.

And that evening, the ice cream had never been better. Feeling a bit petty, she took a photo of her dish of ice cream and sent it to David with the message, “This is what ice cream looks like, fyi.”

Satisfied, she picked up her spoon, put the exact right amount of ice cream on it, and brought it to her mouth. She closed her eyes and thought, “Delicious.”
Please Rate This Story ?
  • Share this story on
  • 9

ADD COMMENT

COMMENTS (6)

Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.

Aziz

08/25/2023

There is some fun along with enjoyment, and beautiful memories. Very lovely piece of work.

There is some fun along with enjoyment, and beautiful memories. Very lovely piece of work.

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Marla

08/28/2023

Thanks!

Thanks!

Help Us Understand What's Happening

Gerald R Gioglio

08/25/2023

Yum. We got a "Tastee Freese" playing 50-60s music here in colorado springs. Our fav. Your story makes me want to got there. Thanks.

Yum. We got a "Tastee Freese" playing 50-60s music here in colorado springs. Our fav. Your story makes me want to got there. Thanks.

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Marla

09/03/2023

Thanks for reading! Go enjoy that ice cream! :)

Thanks for reading! Go enjoy that ice cream! :)

Help Us Understand What's Happening

BEN BROWN

08/25/2023

That was a great story. I found the end part amusing. Well done for being todays star.

That was a great story. I found the end part amusing. Well done for being todays star.

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Marla

08/25/2023

Thank you, Ben!

Thank you, Ben!

Help Us Understand What's Happening

Shirley Smothers

08/25/2023

Cute story. I often feel disappointed when someone promises one thing but produces something else. I myself used to call popsicles Ice Cream. Kids don't know the difference. Loved reading your story. Congratulations on Short Story Star of the day.

Cute story. I often feel disappointed when someone promises one thing but produces something else. I myself used to call popsicles Ice Cream. Kids don't know the difference. Loved reading your story. Congratulations on Short Story Star of the day.

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Marla

08/25/2023

Thanks, Shirley! I heard about a mom who gave her kids yogurt (regular,not frozen), and told them it was ice cream. Those kids didn’t know what they were missing!

Thanks, Shirley! I heard about a mom who gave her kids yogurt (regular,not frozen), and told them it was ice cream. Those kids didn’t know what they were missing!

Help Us Understand What's Happening

JD

08/24/2023

So.... can't help but wonder.... is any of this story true or is it all 'fiction'?
Another fun read, Marla. Thank you! Happy short story star of the day! : )

So.... can't help but wonder.... is any of this story true or is it all 'fiction'?
Another fun read, Marla. Thank you! Happy short story star of the day! : )

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Marla

08/25/2023

Lol! There was indeed some inspiration behind this one, but the story is fiction.

Lol! There was indeed some inspiration behind this one, but the story is fiction.

Help Us Understand What's Happening

Daniel Hartz

06/21/2023

She shouldnt have been so picky, enjoyed the icicle/popsicle or whatever you want to call at and to put the icing on the cake she still could have had her real ice cream later. Great short btw....

She shouldnt have been so picky, enjoyed the icicle/popsicle or whatever you want to call at and to put the icing on the cake she still could have had her real ice cream later. Great short btw....

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Marla

06/21/2023

She might have been happier if she had done that! Thanks for reading! :)

She might have been happier if she had done that! Thanks for reading! :)

Help Us Understand What's Happening

FOLLOW US ON

  • Twitter

LIKE US ON

  • Facebook

STORY CATEGORIES

  • TRUE LIFE FICTION
  • KIDS TEENS ADULTS ALL AGES

  • Member Websites

QUICK LINKS

  • Publish Story
  • Read Stories
  • Contact us
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy

© 2010-2026 STORY STAR. All rights reserved.

Gift Your Points
( available)
Help Us Understand What's Happening