STORYSTAR
Logo
  • Home
    • Short Story STARS of the Week
    • Short Story Writer of the Month
    • Read short stories by theme
    • Read short stories by subject
    • Read classic short stories
    • Read Novels
    • Brightest Stars Anthology
    • StoryStar Premium Membership
  • Publish Story
  • Read Stories
    • READ SHORT True Life STORIES
    • READ SHORT Fiction STORIES
    • READ SHORT STORIES FOR Kids
    • READ SHORT STORIES FOR Teens
    • READ SHORT STORIES FOR Adults
    • Read short stories by theme
      • Read Short Love stories / Romance Stories
      • Read Short Family & Friends Stories
      • Read Short Survival / Success Stories
      • Read Short Mystery Stories
      • Read Short Inspirational Stories
      • Read Short Drama / Human Interest Stories
      • Read Short Action & Adventure Stories
      • Read Short Science Fiction Stories
      • Read Short Fairy Tales & Fantasy Stories
      • Read Short Story Classics Stories
      • Read Short Horror Stories
    • Read short stories by subject
      • Action
      • Adventure
      • Aging / Maturity
      • Art / Music / Theater / Dance
      • Biography / Autobiography
      • Character Based
      • Childhood / Youth
      • Comedy / Humor
      • Coming of Age / Initiation
      • Community / Home
      • Courage / Heroism
      • Creatures & Monsters
      • Crime
      • Culture / Heritage / Lifestyles
      • Current Events
      • Death / Heartbreak / Loss
      • Drama
      • Education / Instruction
      • Ethics / Morality
      • Fairy Tale / Folk Tale
      • Faith / Hope
      • Family
      • Fantasy / Dreams / Wishes
      • Fate / Luck / Serendipity
      • Flash / Mini / Very Short
      • Friends / Friendship
      • General Interest
      • Ghost Stories / Paranormal
      • History / Historical
      • Horror / Scary
      • Ideas / Discovery / Opinions
      • Inspirational / Uplifting
      • Life Changing Decisions/Events
      • Life Experience
      • Loneliness / Solitude
      • Love / Romance / Dating
      • Memorial / Tribute
      • Memory / Reminiscence
      • Miracles / Wonders
      • Mystery
      • Nature & Wildlife
      • Novels
      • Other / Not Listed
      • Pain / Problems / Adversity
      • Personal Growth / Achievement
      • Pets / Animal Friends
      • Philosophy/Religion/Spirituality
      • Poems & Songs
      • Politics / Power / Abuse of Power
      • Recreation / Sports / Travel
      • Relationships
      • Revenge / Poetic Justice / Karma
      • Science / Science Fiction
      • Seasonal / Holidays
      • Serial / Series
      • Service / Giving Back
      • Survival / Healing / Renewal
      • Time: PAST/Present/FUTURE
      • War & Peace
      • Western / Wild West
  • Contests
  • Blog
  • Comments Feed
  • LOGIN / SIGN UP
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
LOGIN / SIGN UP

Congratulations !


You have been awarded points.
Thank you for !

Storystar Premium Members Don't See Any Advertising. Learn More.

Advertisement

  • Story Listed as: True Life For Adults
  • Theme: Fairy Tales & Fantasy
  • Subject: History / Historical
  • Published: 09/20/2024

Paul Bunyan VS Nanaboozhoo

By Shirley Smothers
Born 1960, F, from San Antonio Texas, United States

Read More Stories by This Author
Paul Bunyan VS Nanaboozhoo

The figure of Bunyan was adapted by the Ojibwe people into folklore about Nanaboozhoo, a hero of the Ojibwe and Annishinaabe.

Nanaboozhoo is depicted as a defender of the Forest, he prevented Paul Bunyan from logging, and cutting down all the trees. He protected the North woods of Minnesota and Wisconsin.

The Ojibwe have a story about Paul Bunyan. He came to the area known as Red Lake and tried to cut down all the trees, but Nanaboozhoo - The Greatest Ojibwe who ever lived - wasn't having any of that. They got into a fight that lasted 3 days, and finally the hero picked up a giant walleye and slapped the enemy silly with it. Paul got knocked on his butt in a mud puddle, so hard it left an imprint there in the wet ground, that's why the lake is shaped the way it is and why they were able to keep the Wilderness.

This story may never appear in a book, but it has been passed down from one generation to another. The town of Bemidj was said to be Paul's favorite. That's the story behind the Paul/Babe & Nanaboozhoo statues in that town. There used to be a sign but is was said the chimooks didn't like it and kept cutting it down.

While Bunyan’s fictional crew is European American, Native men also labored in logging camps. It allowed many Native workers to earn wages  and remain close to their homelands. Other Native people, meanwhile, created Paul Bunyan tales of their own. By the late 1800s, Ojibwe storytellers explained the preservation of forests at Red Lake by saying that Bunyan had lost a fight with Nanabozho, the mythical Ojibwe trickster hero who predated him.

This story emphasizes the importance of preserving the natural environment. Cut down trees, but replace them. Let’s all be cautious about the Carbon footprints we leave on our Earth.

Paul Bunyan VS Nanaboozhoo(Shirley Smothers) The figure of Bunyan was adapted by the Ojibwe people into folklore about Nanaboozhoo, a hero of the Ojibwe and Annishinaabe.

Nanaboozhoo is depicted as a defender of the Forest, he prevented Paul Bunyan from logging, and cutting down all the trees. He protected the North woods of Minnesota and Wisconsin.

The Ojibwe have a story about Paul Bunyan. He came to the area known as Red Lake and tried to cut down all the trees, but Nanaboozhoo - The Greatest Ojibwe who ever lived - wasn't having any of that. They got into a fight that lasted 3 days, and finally the hero picked up a giant walleye and slapped the enemy silly with it. Paul got knocked on his butt in a mud puddle, so hard it left an imprint there in the wet ground, that's why the lake is shaped the way it is and why they were able to keep the Wilderness.

This story may never appear in a book, but it has been passed down from one generation to another. The town of Bemidj was said to be Paul's favorite. That's the story behind the Paul/Babe & Nanaboozhoo statues in that town. There used to be a sign but is was said the chimooks didn't like it and kept cutting it down.

While Bunyan’s fictional crew is European American, Native men also labored in logging camps. It allowed many Native workers to earn wages  and remain close to their homelands. Other Native people, meanwhile, created Paul Bunyan tales of their own. By the late 1800s, Ojibwe storytellers explained the preservation of forests at Red Lake by saying that Bunyan had lost a fight with Nanabozho, the mythical Ojibwe trickster hero who predated him.

This story emphasizes the importance of preserving the natural environment. Cut down trees, but replace them. Let’s all be cautious about the Carbon footprints we leave on our Earth.

Please Rate This Story ?
  • Share this story on
  • 7

ADD COMMENT

COMMENTS (9)

Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.

Jessica M.

05/05/2025

We definitely need more people like Nanaboozhoo nowadays that are striving to protect our planet. It's good to hear these stories that aren't widely known. Thanks for sharing this, Shirley!

We definitely need more people like Nanaboozhoo nowadays that are striving to protect our planet. It's good to hear these stories that aren't widely known. Thanks for sharing this, Shirley!

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Shirley Smothers

05/05/2025

Thank you Jessica. I love that Native Americans have their own tales. I wish we could be more aware of these. Thanks

Thank you Jessica. I love that Native Americans have their own tales. I wish we could be more aware of these. Thanks

Help Us Understand What's Happening

Barry

05/02/2025

Wonderful story! I absolutely love it! Many Indian folk tales like you describe are quite sophisticated and overflow with clever social satire.

Wonderful story! I absolutely love it! Many Indian folk tales like you describe are quite sophisticated and overflow with clever social satire.

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Shirley Smothers

05/02/2025

Thank you Barry. When I was a Kid I used to love the stories of Paul Bunyan. As an Adult I realize many acres of Trees were lost to greed. Thank you again.

Thank you Barry. When I was a Kid I used to love the stories of Paul Bunyan. As an Adult I realize many acres of Trees were lost to greed. Thank you again.

Help Us Understand What's Happening

Kevin Hughes

10/02/2024

Hey Shirley,
Never heard this side of the tale before! Wonderful. And congrats on StoryStar of the Week too!
Smiles, Kevin

Hey Shirley,
Never heard this side of the tale before! Wonderful. And congrats on StoryStar of the Week too!
Smiles, Kevin

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Shirley Smothers

10/02/2024

Thank you Kevin. I recently discovered this myself. I love Native American tales. Thank you again.

Thank you Kevin. I recently discovered this myself. I love Native American tales. Thank you again.

Help Us Understand What's Happening

Cheryl Ryan

10/02/2024

I am stoked to see this timeless folktale about Paul Bunyan told differently. The tales had it said that he helped his father cut down trees because he was very huge and had the strength of many men. So I understand now why Nanaboozhoo was trying to stop him and save the environment which I think is fair.
Thank you for sharing!

I am stoked to see this timeless folktale about Paul Bunyan told differently. The tales had it said that he helped his father cut down trees because he was very huge and had the strength of many men. So I understand now why Nanaboozhoo was trying to stop him and save the environment which I think is fair.
Thank you for sharing!

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Shirley Smothers

10/02/2024

Thank you Cheryl. I love to hear or find Native American tales. Thank you for your support.

Thank you Cheryl. I love to hear or find Native American tales. Thank you for your support.

Help Us Understand What's Happening

Joel Kiula

10/01/2024

People doing much for the society even in the past. Wonderful story you have shared with us. Thank you

People doing much for the society even in the past. Wonderful story you have shared with us. Thank you

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Shirley Smothers

10/01/2024

Thank you Joel. I believe the Native Americans treated Mother Earth as a deity. Maybe we should take a few lessons from them. Thank you again.

Thank you Joel. I believe the Native Americans treated Mother Earth as a deity. Maybe we should take a few lessons from them. Thank you again.

Help Us Understand What's Happening

JD

09/29/2024

Intriguing and informative. Thanks for sharing this true story with us, Shirley. Happy short story star of the week.

Intriguing and informative. Thanks for sharing this true story with us, Shirley. Happy short story star of the week.

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Shirley Smothers

09/30/2024

Thank you JD for this honor. Thank you for your kind words. I do like that Native Americans have their story.

Thank you JD for this honor. Thank you for your kind words. I do like that Native Americans have their story.

Help Us Understand What's Happening

Meena

09/23/2024

Thanks for sharing ...

Thanks for sharing ...

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Shirley Smothers

09/23/2024

Thank you Meena. I like that Native Americans had their own story of Paul Bunyan. It's nice to have two versions. Thank you again

Thank you Meena. I like that Native Americans had their own story of Paul Bunyan. It's nice to have two versions. Thank you again

Help Us Understand What's Happening

Aziz

09/22/2024

Beautifully written and the noble message is strong.

Beautifully written and the noble message is strong.

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Shirley Smothers

09/23/2024

Thank you Aziz. It's nice to know Native Americans have their own story about Paul Bunyan. Over cutting of Trees is a problem and leads to extinction and climate change. Thanks again.

Thank you Aziz. It's nice to know Native Americans have their own story about Paul Bunyan. Over cutting of Trees is a problem and leads to extinction and climate change. Thanks again.

Help Us Understand What's Happening

Gerald R Gioglio

09/21/2024

A fascinating native tale. A timely message. Very cool.

A fascinating native tale. A timely message. Very cool.

Reply
Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
some-data...

Shirley Smothers

09/21/2024

Thank you Gerald. It is nice to hear about Native American Culture. Thank you again.

Thank you Gerald. It is nice to hear about Native American Culture. Thank you again.

Help Us Understand What's Happening
Storystar Premium Members Don't See Any Advertising. Learn More.

Advertisement

FOLLOW US ON

  • Twitter

LIKE US ON

  • Facebook

STORY CATEGORIES

  • TRUE LIFE FICTION
  • KIDS TEENS ADULTS

QUICK LINKS

  • Publish Story
  • Read Stories
  • Contact us
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy

© 2010-2025 STORY STAR. All rights reserved.

Gift Your Points
( available)
Help Us Understand What's Happening