Congratulations !
You have been awarded points.
Thank you for !
- Story Listed as: Fiction For Adults
- Theme: Drama / Human Interest
- Subject: Character Based
- Published: 12/16/2025
The Cocktail Pianist
Born 1945, M, from Boston/MA, United States
I paid the bill, leaving a generous tip, and entered the bar, where the pianist was moving briskly through the bridge of Up Jumper Spring, a jazz waltz. Hunched over the keyboard was a petite, plain-featured woman in her late thirties. The watery hazel eyes and meager, unprepossessing mouth only added to a diffident impression. Not that looks mattered; none of the patrons seemed to be paying much attention. In the far corner of the lounge a portly man with a Vandyke beard was blathering away nonstop, holding court with a captive audience of fellow drinkers. He never came up for air, ignoring the live music, which he probably viewed as an inconvenience, an annoying distraction.
“Excuse me,” I noted when the tune ended, “In the last set you finished the Erroll Garner tune with a rather unusual series of block chords.”
A faintly evanescent smile drifted across the woman's face. “You must be a musician,” she deflected the conversation elsewhere.
“And how would you know that?”
“Only another musician would recognize the composer.”
“I’m a trumpeter and teach music at Brandenburg High School,” I explained, “but your playing is lightyears ahead of my skills.
After a brief pause the woman fingered a group of block chords with her left hand.”
“Yes, that’s what I was wondering about!"
“It’s a deceptive cadence.” She repeated the harmonic passage several times in rapid succession. “In the key of F major you simply move up a minor third, then a series of fourths that leave you hovering on the F-sharp.” She ran through the cadence once again.”
“Which resolves a half tone down to the original key,” I noted.
The cocktail pianist nodded. “Imitation being the sincerest form of flattery, I conveniently borrowed the lick from the jazz saxophonist, John Coltrane.”
I shook my head in disbelief. The woman made it sound so easy. In all fairness most of my training had been in the classical realm. In college I played in wind symphonies and several baroque brass ensembles, but sophisticated jazz theory was beyond my abilities. The cocktail pianist glanced up at the clock. "I've got to get back to work.”
“Then I won’t hold you.” I rose and dropped a ten dollar bill in the tip jar. “Coming out to dinner tonight, I was in an atrocious mood. A letter arrived from California that pretty much ruined my day, but talking with you has set things right again.”
The woman studied me curiously, trying to decipher my intent. “Who do you know in California?”
“No one. Never even been there.” I waved a hand dismissively in the air. “But you should get back to the ivories, and I have no intention of boring you with the details of my lackluster life. I’m going home and work out that progression on the horn.”
The cocktail pianist stared thoughtfully into the rear of the room where the garrulous egomaniac with the Vandyke beard was still holding court. “A trumpet is a single-line instrument, so you can't sustain block chords in your left hand like a pianist or guitar player. Best to blow through the individual notes using pentatonic scales. That way you can hear the harmonic flow, the direction the music is taking.” “One, flat-three, four, four’” she repeated. The progression works equally well in all keys."
* * * * *
When I reached home the sun had already gone down. I took a quick shower and brewed a cup of coffee. In the den I eased the trumpet from the case and began my warmup drills - a series of melodic flow studies, arpeggios, long tones and intervallic lip slurs. “How utterly clever!” I mused. “The notion of shifting about the standard chords, while reinventing the music.” Root, flatted-third, then up a fourth and still yet another fourth.” “What was it she said before turning back to the keyboard? Pianists and guitar players had a distinct advantage with advanced harmonics; better to use pentatonics when playing a single line instrument.”
Raising the horn to my lips, I started the symmetrical pattern but never survived a meager handful of notes. Grabbing a piece of music paper I scribbled a series of scales - a musical roadmap of sorts - then tried negotiating the harmonic terrain again. “Yes, there it was! Once the angular line shifted to the A-flat, the harmonic tension was palpable and continued unabated until reaching the slightly dissonant F-sharp and quickly resolving back to the original key. Over the next half hour, I wrote out several additional progressions in neighboring keys and worked out the fingerings on the horn before packing the instrument away and scurrying off to bed.
“Who do you know from California?” the cocktail pianist inquired. The letter was from a law firm in San Francisco, notifying me that my wife, who I had neither seen or heard from since she deserted me over a year ago, was filing for divorce. Denise, the fashion plate with the svelte body and gorgeous looks, was a real estate broker with superb business skills but no conscience or moral creed. She lived for one express purpose: to make money. More and more and more money! One day following breakfast shortly after we were married I noticed Denise reading through the obituaries in the local Brandenburg Gazette. “Did someone die?” I asked.
Denise’s impeccable features lit up with a brazen smile. “Sometimes I attend funerals or wakes and hand out business my cards to the bereaved… suggest that they might want to consider selling their house and downsizing to a condominium or rental property.”
A queasy sensation welled up in my stomach. “Is that proper?”
Denise didn’t seem the least bit ruffled by my pointed question. “The strategy pays off,” she countered smugly. “I already sold three houses this year alone from condolence visits and raked in an additional hefty commission after selling a property and relocating the lonely widow to a plush, one-bedroom condo.”
A year and a half into the marriage I came home one day to find my wife’s side of the bedroom closet cleaned out. There was no note by way of explanation. She had packed her belongings and fled to destinations unknown. I called my sister-in-law later that evening. “Denise is gone,” I said in a choked voice.”
“She told me she was leaving you,” she replied in a dry monotone, then the phone fell silent.”
“Do you know where my wife went?”
“Yes, but she told me not to share that information.”
* * * * *
Over the next few months I stopped by the Mill House Restaurant lounge to listen to the cocktail pianist and discuss her unique approach. From an early age the woman amassed a broad collection of substitute chords and voicings that she sprinkled throughout her tunes. “I see a dominant seventh and visualize half-tone whole-tone diminished sevenths, tritones, alt sevenths or even whole-tone scales.”
“But the whole tone scale contains both flatted and raised fifths,” I protested, “which don’t properly belong in a dominant scale.”
“Think of them simply as tensions,” the pianist argued, “upward extensions of the same chord.”
I was having a difficult time wrapping my brain around her unfamiliar logic. “An octave above they become a sharp eleven and flatted thirteenth.”
She cracked a gossamer thin, wispy smile. “Now you’re thinking like a true jazz aficionado!" After a while she tapped me gently on the wrist and whispered, “That’s a sad one at the bar.”
I glanced up at a middle-age woman in a low-cut black sheath dress sipping a martini while bantering with a rotund, balding man. Always arriving alone, she visited the lounge on a regular basis, sat near the draft beer dispenser and left with different men as the establishment neared closing. “There’s nothing smutty or vulgar about her,” the pianist noted. “The lounge lizard simply confuses sex with intimacy.”
“Been there done that,” I admitted not without a hint of mortification.
“Since I was a young girl, I wanted to play piano like Bill Evans, but he was such a one-of-a-kind, musical genius.” “I studied Even’s rhythmic style, voicings… the cascading triplet figures but to no avail.” “In the end I came away with little more than an affinity for his delicate touch.” The pianist played a single chord with the fingers of her left hand, an infinite richness and sonority pervading the sound. “ “That much… nothing else.”
“A major accomplishment in its own right,” I noted.
The lights blinked off and on several times indicating that the lounge would be closing shortly. “The first time you stopped by,” the cocktail pianist said, shifting gears, “you mentioned receiving a letter from someone you never met, who lived in a state you hadn’t visited. ” The comment caught me totally off guard, but I told her in fairly graphic detail about my wife’s abrupt departure. “Did you love the woman?” the piano player inquired.
“Yes, I loved her but in hindsight chose poorly and for all the wrong reasons.” “I’m closer to you than I ever was with her.” I rose to leave. “I’ll see you again next week.”
“I won’t be here.” Once more the pianist’s unremarkable features melted in a feathery-soft, thistledown smile. “They’re refurbishing the bar, adding new light fixtures and a brass railing around the mahogany bar. I’ll be returning a week from Saturday.”
“I’ll see you then.”
- Share this story on
- 1
Gerald R Gioglio
01/11/2026Nice, sleek, realistic and compelling. Congrats Barry. Happy StoryStar week.
ReplyHelp Us Understand What's Happening
Valerie Allen
01/07/2026A low profile love story-the best kind! Those who find a mutual interest and share the joy of that experience will likely feel the love as their relationship grows. Nice story ~
ReplyHelp Us Understand What's Happening
Kevin Hughes
01/06/2026Barry ...I am breathless. And Jason posted a better way to tell you why. My ears heard the music, my heart saw the connection. Harmony in words. Wow.
Smiles, Kevin
Help Us Understand What's Happening
Barry
01/06/2026Kevin,
There is a pantheistic quality in the harmonic structure of modern jazz music. You have to see God in the repetitious themes that move with sublime, symmetrical perfection through the maze of intervals. What the pianist talks about from the outset is quite basic stuff. Some really gifted musicians can take things to a level far beyond my limited grasp.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
Kankana Kriti
01/06/2026This story is a beautiful exploration of music, connection, and human emotions. The way you weave together music theory, character development, and emotional depth is truly captivating. Happy Short Story Star of the Week Barry !!
ReplyHelp Us Understand What's Happening
Noah Redondo
01/05/2026The explanations of the music was really cool to see in this story and I liked those conversations in the bar revolving around those kinds of lessons that aren't just about music either. Great job!
ReplyHelp Us Understand What's Happening
Barry
01/05/2026Thanks Noah. I do play the trumpet but am nothing more than an intermediate level musician. I am, however, obsessed with music theory and have written a few articles about jazz harmony in music publications over the years.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
DA
01/04/2026You really showed your knowledge of music with this one. I liked the way that you edged your characters together without their even exchanging names. Happy Fiction Story of the Week!
ReplyHelp Us Understand What's Happening
Barry
01/05/2026Musicians tend to obsess over this sort of stuff. Music theory and chords are amazing things once you begin to understand the inherent logic (i.e. there's a lot of math involved because of intervals and how they alter sound). In my early eighties, I still play cornet but no longer in jazz or classical orchestras. You can never stop learning new things about music; the subject is truly infinite.
Help Us Understand What's Happening
Jason James Parker
12/19/2025Impeccably written, Barry. You articulate complex ideas fluidly and build worlds upon them that transcend the bounds of short-form.
ReplyHelp Us Understand What's Happening
Kevin Hughes
01/06/2026Jason, I told Barry to read your comment, because doggone it, you expressed what I was feeling much better than I could. This is beyond the pale! Thanks for the right words! Smiles, Kevin
COMMENTS (7)