STORYSTAR
Logo
  • Home
    • Short Story STARS of the Week
    • Short Story Writer of the Month
    • Read short stories by theme
    • Read short stories by subject
    • Read classic short stories
    • Read Novels
    • Brightest Stars Anthology
    • StoryStar Premium Membership
  • Publish Story
  • Read Stories
    • READ SHORT True Life STORIES
    • READ SHORT Fiction STORIES
    • READ SHORT STORIES FOR Kids
    • READ SHORT STORIES FOR Teens
    • READ SHORT STORIES FOR Adults
    • READ SHORT STORIES FOR All Ages
    • Read short stories by theme
      • Read Short Love stories / Romance Stories
      • Read Short Family & Friends Stories
      • Read Short Survival / Success Stories
      • Read Short Mystery Stories
      • Read Short Inspirational Stories
      • Read Short Drama / Human Interest Stories
      • Read Short Action & Adventure Stories
      • Read Short Science Fiction Stories
      • Read Short Fairy Tales & Fantasy Stories
      • Read Short Story Classics Stories
      • Read Short Horror Stories
      • Read Short Gothic Stories
    • Read short stories by subject
      • Action
      • Adventure
      • Aging / Maturity
      • Art / Music / Theater / Dance
      • Biography / Autobiography
      • Character Based
      • Childhood / Youth
      • Comedy / Humor
      • Coming of Age / Initiation
      • Community / Home
      • Contests
      • Courage / Heroism
      • Creatures & Monsters
      • Crime
      • Culture / Heritage / Lifestyles
      • Current Events
      • Death / Heartbreak / Loss
      • Drama
      • Education / Instruction
      • Ethics / Morality
      • Fairy Tale / Folk Tale
      • Faith / Hope
      • Family
      • Fantasy / Dreams / Wishes
      • Fate / Luck / Serendipity
      • Flash / Mini / Very Short
      • Friends / Friendship
      • General Interest
      • Ghost Stories / Paranormal
      • History / Historical
      • Horror / Scary
      • Ideas / Discovery / Opinions
      • Inspirational / Uplifting
      • Life Changing Decisions/Events
      • Life Experience
      • Loneliness / Solitude
      • Love / Romance / Dating
      • Memorial / Tribute
      • Memory / Reminiscence
      • Miracles / Wonders
      • Mystery
      • Nature & Wildlife
      • Novels
      • Other / Not Listed
      • Pain / Problems / Adversity
      • Personal Growth / Achievement
      • Pets / Animal Friends
      • Philosophy/Religion/Spirituality
      • Poems & Songs
      • Politics / Power / Abuse of Power
      • Prior Contests
      • Recreation / Sports / Travel
      • Relationships
      • Revenge / Poetic Justice / Karma
      • Science / Science Fiction
      • Seasonal / Holidays
      • Serial / Series
      • Service / Giving Back
      • Survival / Healing / Renewal
      • Time: PAST/Present/FUTURE
      • War & Peace
      • Western / Wild West
  • Contests
  • Blog
  • Comments Feed
  • LOGIN / SIGN UP
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
LOGIN / SIGN UP

Congratulations !


You have been awarded points.
Thank you for !

  • Story Listed as: Fiction For G rated stories
  • Theme: Drama / Human Interest
  • Subject: Comedy / Humor
  • Published: 11/02/2026

The Robbery That Never Happened

By Rich Puckett
Born 1954, M, from St Louis Mo, United States
View Author Profile
Read More Stories by This Author
The Robbery That Never Happened

The Robbery That Never Happened

 

A Carter County Story

 

In every small town in the Ozarks, and likely in just about every other place in America, the little general store was the hub of life. Ellsinore was fortunate enough to have two of them: McDaniel’s and Jamison’s. Folks liked having a choice. It let them split their spending, keep an eye on their credit, and feel like they had a little control over their money.

 

So when Jamison’s was supposedly robbed in 1972, it caused quite a stir.

 

It had started as a day like any other. The store was busy, as usual. Mr. Jamison, with the kids off at school, was hauling feed sacks, selling wire nails and staples—the big U-shaped nails used to fasten barbed wire to fence posts—and stocking shelves. Mrs. Jamison ran the cash register, stepping away now and then to help someone like Miss Mary Holley, who was too short to reach the top shelf where the cornmeal sat.

 

They had hired a fellow named Luke, who went to First Baptist, the independent Baptist church in town. He worked the lunchmeat counter and served as the butcher. He didn’t sell much fancy meat. Mostly ground beef, a roast now and then, and pork chops if someone wanted them.

 

Farmers bought ground beef because most didn’t have grinders of their own. It was too much trouble. They butchered hogs when they needed to, raised a calf here and there, and eventually most families butchered their own beef. But not everybody did, so Luke stayed busy.

 

Lunchmeat was a whole different matter. In the 1960s and early 1970s, lunchmeat was cheap, and it mattered. Sandwiches weren’t just for lunch. Men carried them to the sawmill, out to the woods to cut logs, and even to the river when they went fishing.

 

Modern snacks like potato chips, popcorn, Fritos, and cheese curls were generally bought for special occasions. If you wanted a snack before bed, you made a sandwich. Maybe you even fried up some bologna and made yourself a hot one.

 

That was the way things were, and nobody thought much about it. You used what you had, bought what you needed, and made do with the rest.

 

So the store stayed busy all day.

 

When school let out, the Jamison kids came in to help. Their oldest daughter, Susie, had already graduated and gone off to college. The younger daughter, Katy, had just started high school, and her brother Steve was a year or two ahead of her.

 

Both were good at the butcher counter. Luke had to get home to his own family, and either one of the kids could run the register. They knew how to stock shelves, too, and Steve especially took over carrying feed sacks out to load onto Parker’s old pickup or Lionel’s flatbed.

 

Jamison’s usually closed around eight in the evening, so family suppers ran late. And in a religious community like Ellsinore, everyone knew that if you needed anything for Sunday—an extra loaf of bread or a pound of bologna—you had better get it on Saturday. The stores were closed on the Lord’s Day. That was family time, a day of rest.

 

Running a general store took dedication. It took compassion, and sometimes mercy. But most of all, it took hard work from every member of the family.

 

And on that ordinary, busy day in 1972, all that hard work was already in motion long before anybody realized something was wrong.

 

Mrs. Jamison still had her apron on when she rang up Sally Parker, giving her the usual friendly reminder that she was getting close to her credit limit. Sally laughed it off. Everybody did. Mrs. Jamison was just finishing the bag when Mr. Jamison hollered from the back of the store.

 

“Hey, dear! Can you come back here and give me a hand? This is too heavy for me to pick up.”

 

She called back, “George, can’t you wait until the kids get home?”

 

If you were a regular customer, you wouldn’t have thought a thing about that. The store was more home to the Jamisons than their house ever was.

 

But George yelled again, a little sharper this time.

 

“Ethel, I need to do this right now. Please come help.”

 

“All right, George, all right,” she said.

 

She handed Sally her bag, then walked to the back and climbed the little set of stairs to the upper level. Together they lifted a heavy sack, something from the hardware line, onto a shelf. She didn’t even look at what it was. She had handled thousands of them.

 

By the time she got back to the register, Katy had come in from school, excited and waving her test scores. Mrs. Jamison gave them a quick glance, but Mr. Walker was already waiting at the counter.

 

Before she could say more, Luke hollered from the butcher shop.

 

“Hey, Ethel! Can you watch the lunchmeat counter? I’ve gotta go to the walk-in and get some pork chops!”

 

She turned to her daughter.

 

“Katy, take over this customer. I’ll look at your test later.”

 

The store was hopping. Katy checked out Mr. Walker. Steve came in right behind her, barely getting a hello out before George yelled down from the upper level.

 

“Steve! Go down to the basement. We had a load come in today—feed sacks. They need to be stacked right.”

 

“Okay, Pa!” he yelled back, heading straight downstairs.

 

It was like that every day: constant motion, constant work, and everybody doing whatever needed to be done.

 

Around eight o’clock, Mr. Jamison would come down to close out the register.

 

The register wasn’t modern. It was the old push-button kind, where the numbers flipped up in a little glass window and the drawer popped open with a clatter. Inside were the slots for hundreds, fifties, twenties, tens, fives, ones, and the little change boxes.

 

On a normal day, the store took in about $500 in cash, sometimes more. They never kept all of it in the top drawer. When the bills stacked too high, they moved the extra down to the lower drawer beneath it.

 

George opened the register.

 

There was one hundred-dollar bill.

 

No fifties.

 

One twenty.

 

One ten.

 

One five.

 

Two ones.

 

That had never happened. Not in twenty years of running the store.

 

He pulled open the lower drawer.

 

Empty.

 

Not a nickel. Not a dime. Not a single bill.

 

Panic hit him like a blow.

 

“Ethel!” he shouted. “Get down here. Quick!”

 

He wasn’t calling her to help with a heavy sack this time.

 

She rushed down. He pointed at the empty drawer, and she stared at it, stunned.

 

“Well, this doesn’t make sense,” she said. “I didn’t take the money out.”

 

They called the kids. Katy and Steve shook their heads. They hadn’t touched it.

 

Luke had left two hours earlier. He wouldn’t have known anything about the money.

 

“When’s the last time you looked in the register?” George asked.

 

“About thirty minutes ago,” she said. “I checked out the last customer.”

 

“Who was the last customer?”

 

She opened the drawer where they kept the receipt books.

 

“It was that Carson boy.”

 

Katy spoke up.

 

“You mean Alan Carson?”

 

Ethel nodded.

 

“Yes.”

 

Steve frowned.

 

“I hate to accuse anybody, but Alan’s got a bad reputation. Remember last year? He stole that car.”

 

“Right off the Gulf station’s parking lot,” Katy added.

 

“Whose car was it?” George asked.

 

“Abraham’s,” Steve said. “But Alan claimed he had permission.”

 

“Well, he didn’t have permission to get into this cash drawer,” George said.

 

“How much do you reckon was taken?” Katy asked.

 

Ethel answered, “I counted it just before Luke left. There was $600 in the cash drawer and about $200 in the register. We had a big day.”

 

George blew out a breath.

 

“Somebody better call Yancy.”

 

Katy went to the wall phone near the door. It was the one everybody used for local calls, and for long-distance calls if they paid at the register. Every cashier kept an eye on that phone.

 

She dialed Yancy, the town marshal and county deputy.

 

Yancy was aggravated. He had just sat down to watch his favorite television show, but when he heard what had happened, he grabbed his hat, strapped on his gun—which he hardly ever carried—and rushed out the door toward Jamison’s.

 

Yancy arrived at the store with his hat still in his hand, scratching his chin like he always did when he didn’t know where to start. He looked at George and Ethel.

 

“Is it possible,” he asked slowly, “that you might’ve put the money somewhere else? Maybe set it aside?”

 

George shook his head.

 

“We’ve searched every place around the counter. There’s no money here. It’s just gone.”

 

Ethel stepped forward, holding the receipt book.

 

“Alan Carson was the last customer I checked out.”

 

Yancy sighed.

 

“Well, I guess I better go talk to him.”

 

“I’m going with you,” George said.

 

“I don’t know if that’s necessary,” Yancy replied.

 

“I couldn’t go home and eat a bite until this is settled. I’m going.”

 

So they climbed into Yancy’s car and drove out to the Carson place.

 

Mr. Carson met them at the door. When they asked to speak to Alan, the boy looked at them with wide eyes.

 

“Are you accusing me?”

 

Yancy held up a hand.

 

“We’re not accusing anybody.”

 

George added, “You were the last person Ethel checked out today. We thought you might’ve seen something.”

 

Alan’s father bristled.

 

“You can search his room. Search our house. Search our old pickup. But when you don’t find anything, you’re gonna owe us an apology.”

 

“Calm down,” Yancy said. “We’re not searching anything. We’re just asking.”

 

Alan shrugged.

 

“I didn’t see anything strange. Except I did see Mrs. Jamison finish counting the money. She put it in one of those little brown cloth sacks and stuck it in the drawer.”

 

George leaned forward.

 

“Did you notice if she put a yellow slip in it? The deposit total?”

 

“I didn’t pay any attention. Why would I care?”

 

They drove away with no answers.

 

“We’re no closer to finding the money than we were,” George said. “This is big, Yance. I don’t know how we’re gonna recover.”

 

“I don’t know who else to talk to,” Yancy admitted. “We could go through the receipt books and talk to every customer you had today.”

 

“That’ll just make folks mad,” George said. “They’ll all go down to McDaniel’s and start shopping there. That’d put me out of business.”

 

They drove back to the store. The kids had gone home, and the place was quiet. They turned on the lights and walked around the register area.

 

Then George saw it.

 

Not at the register.

 

Not in the drawers.

 

But lying on the candy bar rack at the checkout line.

 

A scrap of paper.

 

He picked it up and read it.

 

It was a note from their oldest daughter, Susie. She had come home early from Poplar Bluff because her afternoon classes had been canceled. She had taken the money, all of it, along with the deposit slip, and already delivered it to the bank. She wouldn’t be home until late.

 

George stared at the note.

 

“How in the world did this end up over here?”

 

Yancy sat down on the counter, relief washing over him.

 

“I’m glad this mystery’s solved. Wait till I go home and tell Ethel what fools we made of ourselves.” said George.

 

He grinned.

 

“We all have days like that. And I’m glad it wasn’t a real robbery. I had no idea what to do next.” said Yancy.

 

“Nobody’s happier than I am,” George said. “This would’ve been hard to recover. Insurance wouldn’t have helped much. The deductible’s too high.”

 

Yancy clapped him on the back.

 

“Let’s get out of here.”

 

He drove home, and George climbed into his Dodge pickup and headed for the house.

 

When George walked in, he had a big smile on his face. Ethel, Steve, and Katy were sitting in the living room looking like the world had ended.

 

“Why are you smiling?” Ethel asked. “Did you find the money?”

 

“Did Alan have it?” Steve shouted. “I’ll give him a beating tomorrow at school!”

 

“Stop,” George said, holding out the note.

 

“What I can’t figure out,” he added, “is how this paper ended up on the candy bar rack.”

 

Everyone looked at each other.

 

Then Katy spoke up.

 

“I remember that paper. I didn’t read it. It was laying by the register. I picked it up when Jimmy Perkins wanted one of those big PayDay bars, the chocolate-covered ones. He couldn’t reach it, so I went over to get it. I must’ve laid the note down.”

 

She covered her face.

 

“I caused all the trouble.”

 

Relief washed over the room. Then came the laughter.

 

The mystery was solved.

 

But small towns have their own way of spreading news.

 

By morning, Mabel and Mildred had already told half of Ellsinore about the robbery, long before they heard the solution. Folks came into Jamison’s all day, pretending to buy something, just to ask whether the robbers had been caught.

 

What a surprise they got when they learned there had been no robbery at all.

 

And so it was: another story added to the long list of small-town tales in the Ozarks, where trouble sometimes comes from nothing more than a misplaced note and a PayDay candy bar.

 

Author’s Note: This is a complete work of fiction. The characters, events, circumstances, and story are fictional and are not intended to represent any actual person or event.

Please Rate This Story ?
  • Share this story on
  • 0

ADD COMMENT

COMMENTS (0)

Please note the 5,000 character limit for your comment, after which the remaining text will be cut off.

FOLLOW US ON

  • Twitter

LIKE US ON

  • Facebook

STORY CATEGORIES

  • TRUE LIFE FICTION
  • KIDS TEENS ADULTS ALL AGES

  • Member Websites

QUICK LINKS

  • Publish Story
  • Read Stories
  • Contact us
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy

© 2010-2026 STORY STAR. All rights reserved.

Gift Your Points
( available)
Help Us Understand What's Happening